Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Ministry in the Second Society

In the article on Abraham Pierson’s notebook we discussed the ministers who had served in Killingworth during his tenure. We present here a few documents that relate to the Rev. Henry Ely and the Rev. Josiah B. Andrews. The first document concerns the Rev. Ely. The record notes the agreement to set his salary at 90 pounds. Raising funds to provide keep for a minister was one of the primary tasks in any Society. It seemed unimaginable to not have a minister. In town minutes you also see references to assignments and projects to build or maintain housing. Another of the needs commonly discussed was efforts to provide the minister with an adequate supply to fire wood. As we discussed earlier conflicts arose between the Rev. Ely and the Society over the amount of financial and other support he was to receive. The conflict grew to a point that they agreed to part ways. The document reads in part “The Rev. Henry Ely, by mutual agreement, between him and the people was regularly dismissed from the pastoral care of the Church of Christ in this place”. The interesting term and concept here is the idea of being “dismissed”. It is a term used with the church membership as a whole. The term was used as an acknowledgement that the parishioner was being released from his covenants with the Society in order to move to a new Society. Entry into the new Society was noted using the term “received by letter”. This process was in essence a transfer of the blessings of being in Full Communion. It seems that the idea of being unaffiliated or outside of the “watch and care” of a Society was almost unthinkable.------The third document records the ordination of the Rev. Andrews to the role of Minister. “The Reverend Josiah B. Andrews was ordained to the work of the gospel ministry and received the pastoral charge of the 2nd Church of Christ in Killingworth”. Also listed is the quorum of Ministers and Deacons who presided over the ordination. The imagery in this document highlights a religious conundrum that persists to this day. The Congregational movement was one iteration of the broader Protestant movement that had as a core belief the rejection of the Catholics Church’s concept of the need for a priestly class to intercede on our behalf with Heaven. For Congregationalists the role of intersession was filled by the congregation. Yet in their desire to be true to the scriptures and finding themselves still somewhat trapped by their Catholic past they maintained the concept of ordination, which is itself, an argument for Apostolic Succession. To reconcile the conundrum they argued that ordination was only necessary for the sake of authorization and church order. This angst over such doctrinal confusion only increased with time. One of the responses was to try to reform Congregationalism just as it had tried to reform the Anglican Church and Catholicism. Thus we see the rise of the Baptist and Methodists movements. The debates divided movements and even single Societies. It is ironic that the Killingworth Second Society today is without a minister, the result of doctrinal disagreements. These debates touched the average churchgoer and even involved the theological elites on both sides of the Atlantic. A famous example involves John Wesley. After he ordained Thomas Coke a superintendent to administer sacraments to the Methodists, his brother Charles wrote:” So easy are Bishops made, By Man’s or woman’s whim? Wesley, his hands on Coke hath laid, But who laid hands on Him?”. Click on documents to enlarge.

Monday, January 21, 2013

Azuba Griffin and Henry Davis

Leonard/Azuba/ Samuel/ Samuel Griffin of Killingworth------We have been unable to find a probate record for Henry Davis the husband of Azuba Griffin. However their son Leonard left a detailed probate record. Leonard was the only son of Henry and Azuba. Being the only son tradition suggests that he probably ended up with most of his fathers property either by purchase or inheritance or as an inheritance from his mother. Historically the girls received their inheritance in the form of cash or household goods with the property to remain in the family. Based on this premise we can use Leonard’s probate to approximate his fathers and thus gain a sense of what life may have been like for Henry Davis and Azuba Griffin. In one section of the probate is a list of the properties involved. They include the stone house lot with 12 ½ acres, old chimney place lot of 2 ½ acres, 14 acres of salt marsh in Madison, dwelling house, wood house, best barn, and cow house on the east side of the yard all on 52 acres. Also listed were the cow house on the west side of the yard, old barn, old cow house and the cider mill house on 212 acres. It lists two additional lots containing 42 and 49 acres respectively. What conclusions might we draw from this list? 370 acres in 1841 was a large farm. With three separate “cow houses” mentioned it is my assumption that this was primarily a dairy operation, dairy being a major industry in Killingworth. Did the 2 ½ acres at the old chimney lot represent the original home lot of Henry and Azuba ? Was the stone house lot their second home? Did the 212 acres associated with the old barn represent Henry’s farm? Leonard left a bequest to five people in his will. To each of them he granted access to the “cider mill house”. To have a dedicated structure to house a cider mill would seem to indicate that the mill had a fairly large capacity and that it represented a valued resource. A cider mill also would seem to imply apple orchards. Having reviewed a fair number of probate records there are little hints in Leonard’s probate that that would seem to suggest a little affluence. He had enough resources to build a building dedicated to wood storage. This was not only for firewood but probably also finished lumber, which was a commodity, named in many wills including Leonard’s. To each of the people mentioned in his will he left a silk handkerchief. To his son Joel he left a razor and lather box. The household goods, that make up a large part of every probate, were numerous and decidedly upscale. One of the marks of affluence in that age was the possession of books. Leonard’s probate lists the following volumes, Large Bible, Beauties of the Bible, Exposition of the New Testament, Companion to the Alter, Berna Family Worship, History of England, Biographical Dictionary, Webster Dictionary, Morse Geography, Hukeweldins Narrative, Modern Geography, Civil Officer, and Gazetteers. The book list would seem to indicate people studying the issue of religion at home and people with a worldview. It’s an interesting exercise to imagine what the nature of the household that Leonard grew up in was like. To imagine how much of what he became came from his Griffin heritage.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Death of Marah Griffin August 13, 1765

Marah and Samuel Griffin’s marriage lasted a short six years. Yet despite this brief time together they enjoy the legacy of a large and successful posterity. Their posterity is traced mainly through the family names of Kelsey, Doud and Davis. Through our research we have come to know more of their posterity than they, in particular, Marah. We would like to address that topic as best as we can. The date and location for the birth of Marah “Griffin” Griffin remains an open question. The Barbour Collection would seem to suggest that at the time of her marriage she was living in Killingworth with several of her siblings. However there is no record of her parents or a recorded birth date in the existing Killingworth records. Discovering even her last name posed a challenge. In the town records there are several lists of marriages, each covering a few selected years. In these records we see listed husbands and wives with each new bride being listed by her first, and most importantly, last name. On one such list she is identified as Marah “Griffin”. We also see in the records three people who historical context would suggest could very well be her siblings. Ame Griffin who married Elihu Wellman, April 17, 1744, Elizabeth Griffin who married Benjamin Turner, November 15, 1753, Samuel and Marah bought their home lot from Benjamin Turner. The last possible sibling was William Griffin who married Eunice Crane, May 13, 1769. These three additional marriages help establish the presence of a second Griffin family in the Second Society. The First Society had within its boundaries a third identifiable Griffin clan. The existence and identity of that clan was discussed in our article on the family of James N Griffin. Marah’s documentary history in Killingworth starts with her marriage to Samuel Griffin on May 17, 1759 (document). Key for our discussion here is the fact that there remains some confusion concerning the spelling of her first name and the date of her death. In the blog we have made note of the three spellings used in the various records, Marah, Mariah, and Mary. In the documentary history there are only two different spellings. In her marriage record and death records, both found in Volume Two of the Town Records, her name is written as “Marah.” The Barbour Collection is taken from these town records. For her marriage record Barbour used the correct spelling Marah. For her death record there is a transcription error changing the name to Mariah. This entry in the Barbour Collection is the only source for the “Mariah” spelling. In the church records we see listed people who on a yearly basis were admitted to Full Communion. We see Samuel Griffin and Mary the wife of Samuel Griffin listed on July 19, 1761 (document). This record is the source for the name Mary that I have always assumed was a version of Marah. The commonly used date for Marah’s death is the Barbour date of August 13, 1763, which is taken from the town record. (document). As part of the documentation that we are presenting is a notation that is written in Volume Two concerning the section of documents in which this date for Marah’s death is found. It states that these records are themselves a certified copy of other original records (document). As with all transcriptions they presented an opportunity for transcription errors. The three most common numerical errors are between the numbers 1 and 7, 7 and 9, and 3 and 5. In this case I argue that a 5 became a 3 and the Barbour Collection simply passed along the error. The primary argument for a date of 1765 is the birth dates of her children. Together Samuel and Marah had three girls (document). The oldest is Lois (Kelsey) her date of birth, as noted in the concise little family record that was unfortunately smudged, is recorded as November 21, 1760. The church records list Lois as being baptized, along with two other children, January 19th, 1761. The Barbour Collection dates for the three girls are obviously taken from the family record discussed above. For Polly (Doud) the records note that she was born August 13, 1762, and baptized August 15, 1762. They show Azuba (Davis) being born April 9, 1765 and her baptismal date noted in the church records on April 14, 1765. The key dates are for Azuba who was born and baptized in April of 1765 (document). Marah married in 1759, her children were born in 1760, 1762, and 1765. These dates follow a pattern that is very common for the era and can be used as a secondary form of historical verification for family groupings. I propose that Marah died August 13, 1765 leaving Samuel with three young daughters one only months old. Again following a commonly seen historical pattern the records show Samuel remarrying fairly quickly on May 15, 1766 taking Mercy Nettleton as his second wife (document).

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Samuel Nettleton's Earmark

One of the features of the New England landscape is the town common. The town common was used in the earliest days as a common pasture where livestock could be grazed. As towns grew larger they developed other parcels of common ground. This property was marginal for the purpose of agriculture but had a value as grazing land. What you see in the deed and probate records is the right to access these common grounds being passed from one farmer to another and from father to son. In Killingworth such land was referred to as the salt marshes. The existence of common land gave rise to the need to be able to easily identify your own cattle and sheep that were mixed in with those of your neighbors. Thus we see as a prominent feature in all town records the registration of earmarks. Here we have the earmark registry for Samuel Nettleton father of Mercy Nettleton Griffin.

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Birth of the Killingworth Second Society

We have discussed on several occasions the circumstances that gave rise to the Killingworth “Second” Society. We have managed to put together several documents taken from town records that tell the story of the birth of the new Society. The first document is dated December the 12th 1728. The dialog concerning the wants of the people living in what is described, as our northern neighbors the farmers, had gained enough momentum that the town council, made up mainly of men from southern Killingworth, acknowledged that the issue had reached a point where decisions would have to be considered. The second document dated September 18, 1730 states the case for the northerners. Faith is essential to justification. Faith comes by hearing the word Preached. Implied was the fact that it was difficult to make the trip to church in southern Killingworth to hear the word. Then the claiming of the moral high ground, “We hope no good man will deny our Prayer”. The prayer was for the opportunity to hear the word in their own meetinghouse. The discussion was framed by two opposing points of view, stay together and with our pooled tithing money we can build a magnificent new meetinghouse vs. its too hard for us to make the trip south each week. Our needs are for a meetinghouse closer to our homes. But at issue was also the fact that these two groups had become two separate societies with two different sets of priories, one town folk, and the other farmers. On December 24, 1730 the issue came up for a vote. The description in the minutes is that “The meeting was prolonged by a vote in the evening”. Seeming after a prolonged discussion the two groups arrived at a resolution. Identify a line of division and agree to the formation of a new northern Society. The fourth document is the agreed on terms for the division of land and tithing money. The north agreed to help build the new meetinghouse to commence immediately. The south agreed to help the north build a building when the new Society was eventually formed. The last document is the act of authorization passed by the Colonial Assembly. Note it is dated May 12, 1737 some nine years after the first town meeting, seven years after the agreement. The new Killingworth Second Society became the home to the Griffin, Nettleton, Buell, Kelsey, Pelton and Davis families. The Griffin boys met and married the Hull girls in the Second Society, The Doud boys came calling probably at church socials. James Griffin’s sons and grandsons found wives in the second society. And we found our history there.

Monday, January 14, 2013

Congregational Drummers

Ingrained in Americana is the image of the church steeple with its bell. We have a rich cultural tradition of the church bell tolling the hour, peeling out news both good and bad and calling the faithful to Sunday Services. But in the earliest days of America it was the drum that served this function. The town crier announced his presence with the beat of a drum, the militia was directed in many of its functions by drumbeat, and in the Congregational Societies the call to worship was the beating drum. In places where most of the populous lived and worked in town the call to worship was the roll of the drum from the meetinghouse roof. In a farming community like Killingworth it is my guess that the drummer served his function by making a quick ride up and down the two streets that connected the scattered farms. Found in the town records for Killingworth are a number of small documents that note the hiring of a drummer. The fact that this was a matter of town business underlines its importance. Making it to church on time was important. In the earliest days it was mandatory. In our era what we would term as “an announcement” was recorded in early church records as a “warning”. It was not an “announcement” that we are having an event come if you can, instead, it was a “warning” we are having an event, you had bettered come. In the minutes of the Society future plans and events were noted and the line was always added, “and the members were warned”. Church attendance was important, gaining ones salvation was critical, and the drummers sounded the call.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Truman Doud 1784-1828

Truman/Reuben Polly Griffin/Abraham/Abraham/Thomas/Henry Doude------A hearing was held in the Cortland Surrogate Court on October 28, 1834 to establish a final resolution for the estate of Truman Doud. My interpretation of this court proceeding is that it reflects the fact that Truman did not leave a will. Truman died in 1828 at a relatively young age death may have came as a surprise. The transcript for the proceeding is very brief. His wife Rhoda and son in law Jabez Collins served as Administrators. Truman’s children are named in the transcript. Almira/Edwin Cook, Lavinia/Henry Townly, Truman Doud, Enoch H. Doud, Bela P. Doud, Josephine E. Doud.